The Problem With Pretty

katherine webb

(Photo by Matt Cashore, USA TODAY Sports)

Not being much of a football fan, I wasn’t watching when the University of Alabama beat Notre Dame the other night. But being an avid news fan, I couldn’t miss the stories about how sportscaster Brent Musburger raved about Katherine Webb, the beauty queen girlfriend of Alabama quarterback AJ McCarron.

I really didn’t understand all the fuss. Men have been making comments about beautiful women as long as women have been making comments about good looking-men. I may be a feminist, but I also recognize that appreciating beauty is an essential element of human nature.

Initially, I didn’t perceive any problem. At least, I didn’t perceive a problem until I read a story about how Webb and her parents responded to all the fuss.

They weren’t bothered by Musburger’s comments. And why would they have been? Webb is a beauty queen. She struts around in a bikini in front of cameras. She obviously wants to be noticed for her appearance alone, and her subsequent reaction reflected that.

What bothered me was the importance Webb’s parents placed on her being beautiful.

Apparently (according to family), Katherine was once considered an ugly duckling because of a skin condition and her height. Her mother said that being in the Miss USA pageant helped build her daughter’s self-esteem. In other words, her mother believes Katherine’s self-esteem hinges on others’ perceptions of her appearance. And that’s what bothers me about this “news” story.

Self-esteem is complicated. Yet, like so many other issues, people try to simplify it. Several years ago when my children were in elementary school, they attended an assembly about self-esteem.

“What activities did you do? I asked. They looked at me puzzled.

“We didn’t do anything,” my son said. “Some lady just talked to us about how we should have self-esteem.”

We moved on to other subjects, but I was irritated with the school for wasting precious educational hours on some pointless presentation. You can’t teach or preach self-esteem. True and lasting self-esteem is achieved through experiences of success and through overcoming difficult situations. Our responsibility as adults is to provide children with those opportunities.

And self-esteem isn’t an “all or nothing”  concept.

People don’t either have or not have self-esteem. Most of us feel confident in one aspect of our life while struggling in others. When I was younger, I had excellent self-esteem about my intelligence and ability to do well in school because I had volumes of success in academics. I had very poor self-esteem in regards to my appearance because I’d been told I looked like a monkey and was a four on a scale of one to ten.

Experience taught me that what others think of my appearance has absolute nothing to do with my value as a human, my capacity to be loved or my ability to be happy.

But those are lessons I learned from decades of life experience. Katherine Webb doesn’t have that yet.

Instead, she is surrounded by people who put an inordinate value on appearance. People who coach her that plastering on makeup to cover a skin condition is essential. People who have convinced her that fitness means being skinny enough to meet society’s standards for wearing a bikini. People who equate being called beautiful with being accepted.

Maybe I’m being a bit judgmental because I was raised to never rely on my appearances for anything. Sometimes that message was delivered in a subtle manner as my mother never bought fashion magazines nor wore makeup. At other times, the message was delivered loud and clear –  like the time she told me that I was lucky to be smart rather than pretty. And even though those words hurt at the time, they also held a great deal of wisdom.

When you can’t rely on your appearance open doors for you, you develop other skill sets. And those achievements and successes are what truly build self-esteem.

There is nothing wrong with being beautiful, but there is everything wrong when women allow it to define them.

And that’s the problem with pretty.

About Trina Bartlett

I live in the Eastern Panhandle of WV, with one dog, two cats, and a husband who works strange hours. I can generally be found wandering through the woods my dog, playing in and planting in dirt, and generally stirring things up.

Posted on January 12, 2013, in current affairs, Family, My life, perspective and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 15 Comments.

  1. Thanks! This is a great post. 🙂

  2. Nicely said. Yes, it is important to put our best foot forward–I wear a tie when necessary, for example–but what defines us should be so much more.

  3. My thoughts exactly, Trina! Thank you for speaking out on this – I have seen so much hollow coverage on this story. I’m glad you got to the root of the issue here in this post. Looking forward to seeing more!

  4. What you have written is one reason I think you are such a special person to me. You are who you are – what more can anyone ask for – It does take years to finally feel good in your own skin – Some people never do!!!! You have accomplished so much by feeling good with who you are!!!! Thanks for a great blog!!!

    • I constantly struggle with what I supposed do or more often say (as you well know). but I am well over worrying about who I am. Since I can never escape myself, I might as well enjoy who I am… which, if nothing else, can be quite entertaining. (As in, I’m so glad people can’t read all thoughts in my head, because, believe it or not, there are many that I don’t share!)

  5. “What a strange illusion it is to suppose that beauty is goodness.” -Leo Tolstoy

    Though I would add to Tolstoy’s observation of beauty, “that as defined by society.” Love the article, Trina! And, many of us find YOU much more beautiful than Miss Webb.

  6. I learned a lesson about the insane importance we give to looks when I lost 150 pounds. My boss remarked to me that I truly demonstrated my competence through my weight loss. My skills in my job did not change one bit but somehow I was more acceptable to her because I was thin. Had she focused her comments on my health or my perseverance, I would not have been so offended. Let’s face it, the research is clear that pretty people are more successful. It’s an interesting comment on our society. Just ask Susan Boyle. Nice post.

    • 2012 was one of those years when I faced the challenging task of holding my tongue for the sake of self-preservation. I didn’t always do so well, and sometimes this blog was the only way I could say, or at least hint at, the horrendous behavior of others. In one instance, I had to sit back and watch as a very qualified person was denied a job to a person who had none of the qualifications or experience that were required. And I know the reason was because of appearance. Yet I remained quiet because I am already considered to outspoken.So instead, I write and wonder if that does much good at all.

  7. It can be so hurtful and troubling when others use such subjective values to define me because I am so much more. My husband reminds me to be the best me I can be!

  1. Pingback: Being Comfortable In The Skin You’re In | L.E.G.A.C.Y.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: